A different type of religious intolerance – no good without a god?

by Luana Ferreira*

One of the most popular TV channels in Brazil, Band, will dedicate 50 minutes of its prime time airspace to talk about religious diversity and freedom of belief in Brazil. But it was not a decision that came from TV producers and management. It was forced1 upon the network following the decision of Federal Judge Paulo Cezar Neves Junior which condemned the channel for the hate speech against atheists delivered by the TV host José Luiz Datena in July 2010 during his TV Show Brasil Urgente.

The events leading to the Court decision were as follows. On 27 July 2010, during the live show, after reporting on the murder of a child, the TV host went on claiming that only an atheist could have committed such a crime because, according to him, people who do not believe in God have no moral values or boundaries and are capable of doing anything. Later on in the show, the presenter opened a call-in poll in which viewers were invited to answer whether they believed in God or not. Unsurprisingly, the presenter kept motivating believers to call and continued to assure viewers that he did not want atheists watching his show.

Source unknown

Ironically, Brasil Urgente is known for reporting all sorts of crimes with often shocking images, and has built its audience thanks to the actions of people who are – as the presenter believes – “without God”, and without whom he would very likely be either jobless or just another anonymous Brazilian journalist .

Brazil has the largest number of Catholics in the world. It also prides itself on being a country where various beliefs can be expressed without discrimination. However, this may not be the case in practice as, according to research conducted by the Perseu Abramo Foundation in 2009, atheists are the most hated group in Brazil. Perhaps due to their Christian foundations, a large percentage of Brazilians understand God as being synonymous with moral values. Many people still believe that love, goodness, justice, ethics and a sense of empathy with others are only possible with a deity. In other words, humans would not be capable of any good without divine influence. This line of thinking leads to the assumption that a lack of God would bring us to the opposite path: the evil atheist capable of any atrocity. Thinking this way, many reject the notion that it is possible to be good without believing in a god, which then leads to increasing prejudice and discrimination against non-believers in the country.

Media professionals must be aware of their role in society and of their power as opinion leaders. Television, the internet and newspapers are all important tools with the power to both reinforce and to break down prejudices. All professions working with this powerful tool that is communication should be well prepared and aware of the fine line between freedom of speech and hate speech.

In addition to the potential damage directly inflicted on minority groups by comments such as those made by José Luiz Datena on Brasil Urgente, as well as the potential damage done to society as a whole, a further problem is that many will find in Datena’s words an endorsement for their hate. Hate speech, such as that of Mr Datena, in a democratic and modern country as Brazil, which promises to all its citizens the right to express any faith (or no faith at all), goes against one of Brazil’s proudest features. No, I am not talking about samba or football, but the pride Brazilians often display in being a country of diversity. If it is so, there should be no room for discourse suggesting that the world can be divided between good and bad people according to their religious beliefs. Such sentiments should not be aired, especially not during prime time.

1 The network may still appeal the decision.

Human Rights & Democracy has chosen not to share the video of the abovementioned show for finding the content offensive.

Luana Ferreira has studied Journalism and currently works as a Press Officer in São Paulo, Brazil.

Readers are encouraged to quote, reproduce and share this content for educational, non-profit purposes, provided the source is acknowledged. The views expressed in this post are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the HR&D team.


Post a Comment



#niunamenos 16 days academic activism Adam Shapiro Afghanistan Africa apartheid Argentina art asexual asexuality asylum seekers Aung San Suu Kyi Australia Bahrain Bangladesh beauty Brazil Brexit Bulgaria business call for contributions call for papers call for submissions cartoon censorship cfp child labour children Chile cinema civil disobedience civil rights Colombia conference cultural rights democracy detention development discrimination displacement domestic violence ECtHR Ecuador Editors’ notes education Egypt elections empowerment environment equality equity euro crisis Europe events facebook family life fashion fatphobia feminism FGM food for thought freedom of belief freedom of expression freedom of speech gay rights gender gender bias gender violence Google graffiti hate speech health human rights human rights defenders human rights law ICC India indigenous rights infographics internet intimacy Iran Islamophobia Jafar Panahi Kabul Kenya labour rights land rights language language rights law Lesotho LGBTI Liberia Malawi Martin Luther King Maryam Al-khawaja masculinity media men mental health migration minority rights Nauru non-violent resistance offshore processing opinion piece opportunities Papua New Guinea peace Philippines photography poetry politics poverty protest public opinion queer quotes racism Rana Plaza refugee law refugees right to private life right to seek asylum Russia Senegal sexual rights sexuality Singapore social exclusion social inequality South Africa state responsibility stereotype street art Syria terrorism thin privilege trans trans rights transgender translation tribalism Turkey twitter Uganda UK UK referendum UN UNESCO UNHCR US video violence war water women women‘s rights women’s rights youth Zimbabwe

Twitter Updates

Like Us!